A quote by Frank A. Clark

21 Feb 2017

Something inspirational:

“Criticism, like rain, should be gentle enough to nourish a man’s growth without destroying his roots.”


6 Responses to “A quote by Frank A. Clark”

Post a Comment
  1. Randy 21. Feb, 2017 at 1:27 pm #

    People do love to use that term, constructive criticism, but for me I don’t quite hear it that way. I grew up in a world where my mom’s family would talk badly about my dad’s family and my dad would talk badly about my mom’s, so what were we supposed to think?

    Kind of a setup for hating ourselves, since we were a part of both of them. They also like to say that words will never hurt me, but when you hear it day in and day out for your entire childhood, it definitely leaves a lasting impression.

    These are the voices I still hear in the back of my mind that have crushed my spirit and kept me from doing what I always wanted to do. I’m still not quite sure of what those things are, but I do have a bit of time to figure out what things they may turn out to be.

    • Ilana 21. Feb, 2017 at 1:51 pm #

      Thanks Randy, yes there is a difference of course between outright criticism, which is what you had as a child and criticism which is constructive.

      I remember a talk I went to in my daughter’s school, where the Head Teacher was talking about the children’s conduct in school and how if all children had knuckled under more, those children would have achieved success too.

      Anything constructive can help us of course and that starts with our parents. It also depends on who is handing out the criticism, constructive or not. We need to come from a place of care.

      Sadly that didn’t happen for you. As Brad has said in his response, your mum’s behaviour was never about you. I hope you can bring comfort from that.

  2. Brad 21. Feb, 2017 at 2:32 pm #

    Criticism can be harmful so it is important how it is handled. Done properly, it is positive an part of our growth and learning.

    Done negatively as Randy says, can be harmful and demoralising, causing lasting damage. The recipient of negative criticism should take comfort in that the person handing it out has the problem, not the recipient.

    • Ilana 21. Feb, 2017 at 2:48 pm #

      Thank you. Yes, Randy is right. I agree with him also. I love that your last sentence sums up your response. It’s always the person handing out the problem with the problem, never the recipient.

      I think it important we reinforce that in our minds.

  3. Tim 21. Feb, 2017 at 7:05 pm #

    Criticism should be tactful not targeted, choosing tone and words carefully or it may worsen a situation; words in the moment matter.

    • Ilana 21. Feb, 2017 at 8:33 pm #

      Thanks Tim. Yes, you’re absolutely right, words in the moment matter.

      Words usually said in the heat of the moment, usually have far widening repercussions years down the line.

Leave a Reply