Narrative fallacy is when we let a good story cloud the facts, making it harder to think logically. We naturally try to connect facts with explanations, but these explanations can distort reality.

We Should Rely on Facts and Logic

To avoid falling into this trap, we should rely on facts and logic rather than just stories. When looking at the past, narrative fallacy can make us remember things in a way that fits our own version of events. Staying aware of this, helps us to see the truth more clearly. As a general rule, we believe what we’re told without applying facts or logic. A current example is the rhetoric surrounding the Brexit debate going on in the UK, divorced from reality and yet accepted by millions who choose to blindly accept what they're being told. We don’t stop to question others' motives.

Conclusion

Events in history are also based on narrative fallacy and although it's too late for us to change how history played out, it's not too late for us to change what's happening in the here and now. Something we would all be wise to consider.

Ilana Estelle is a mental health and wellbeing advocate who combines educational insight with her personal experience of living with physical, mental, and emotional disabilities. She holds diplomas in Counselling, Diet and Nutrition, Nutritional Therapy, Psychotherapy and Counselling, and Stress Management. Through her writing, Ilana supports others in navigating their emotional, mental, and physical health challenges. In addition to writing for The CP Diary, her work has appeared in healthy lifestyle magazines. Ilana is also the author of three books: Cerebral Palsy: A Story – Finding the Calm After the Storm, Spirituality, Healing and Me, and Survival: The Covid Years – Time for Change.

Most people who read this blog

went on to read these blogs next
Date 29 July 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

Between the Headlines

Protecting Our Peace in an Age of Political Uncertainty Although today's reflection is rooted in politics, it is ultimately about psychology, wellbeing and how we protect our peace in uncertain times. Politics has ...
Read more
Date 27 July 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

Someone Else's Punchbag

The Human Punchbag Most people picture a punchbag hanging in a gym – a heavy bag designed to absorb blow after blow. It serves a purpose. It's expected to take the hits. But there is another kind of punchbag ...
Read more
Date 20 July 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

The Power to Choose

Breaking free from expectations and embracing a life shaped by your own values Empowerment starts when we try something new. It's about taking action and believing that our choices can shape our lives. Many of ...
Read more
1 2 3 522

4 comments on “Narrative Fallacy”

  1. Never in my life have I been more concerned about mass brainwashing and blind obedience that follow. How can reasonably sensible people believe in lies and condemn truth as worthless, it's absolutely crazy?

    But the real tragedy is that those who are in positions to do something about it have remained silent.

    1. Thanks Tim. I think your last paragraph sums up your response beautifully. It becomes a human failing when people choose to ignore their own values and integrity and instead follow others like sheep.

      In politics when politicians choose to ignore the universal truths to gain a vantage point it will only end in tears. I wouldn't normally have a problem with that if it was only their tears.

      I stand by my values and integrity and although that doesn't win me any brownie points because I am too moral, I can live with myself and that matters.

      If more of us did that just think how different the landscape would look.

  2. We do have a tendency to go along with what were told, unchallenging until the blindingly obvious smacks us in the face.

    Your example of the Brexit mess is hugely relevant. Even now, with all the facts to hand, knowing that leaving the EU without a deal will be shooting ourselves in the foot, there is a worrying impetus behind doing just that.

    Sometimes you can take a horse to water but you can't make them understand the fallacy behind the narrative if they don't want to.

    1. I agree with you. If people choose to stay in denial just so they get what they want, there isn't much we can do.

      With Brexit, I still live with positivity and hope that common sense will eventually prevail. It needs to.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to receive regular updates

Enter your details below to be the first to receive updates on new articles on my blog.