As children, we trust our parents and don't stop to question whether what they thought was best for us was the best; as children I’m not sure we’re equipped.

It became clear that decisions being made around my disability were wrong that where our parents have our backs, they may sometimes have their own.

We're not always in a position to consider how valid and reliable their information is, what the merits are and whether the information being presented are really being made in our own interests and whether they are right for us.

Parents may continue to evaluate things for their children through their own evaluations. The same principles apply to other areas too. When we use critical evaluation, we’re working on developing our own understanding in more detail.

As children when we're old enough, it is important we evaluate and judge things for ourselves, so that we come to understand our lives better.

Ilana Estelle is a mental health and wellbeing advocate who combines educational insight with her personal experience of living with physical, mental, and emotional disabilities. She holds diplomas in Counselling, Diet and Nutrition, Nutritional Therapy, Psychotherapy and Counselling, and Stress Management. Through her writing, Ilana supports others in navigating their emotional, mental, and physical health challenges. In addition to writing for The CP Diary, her work has appeared in healthy lifestyle magazines. Ilana is also the author of three books: Cerebral Palsy: A Story – Finding the Calm After the Storm, Spirituality, Healing and Me, and Survival: The Covid Years – Time for Change.

Most people who read this blog

went on to read these blogs next
Date 22 October 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

Do You Have To Forgive?

Finding closure by letting go of guilt and responsibility that were never yours to carry Every child has a right to know who they are and what they are living with. This is part of my healing journey. I spent much of my ...
Read more
Date 19 October 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

The Understanding I Didn't Have

Living With Cerebral Palsy and Autism Six decades of living with cerebral palsy and autism without the understanding that might have helped me make sense of myself. What happens when you go through life with ...
Read more
Date 17 October 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

Healing Without All The Answers

Living With Unanswered Questions There comes a time when trying to understand your past means accepting that not everything will be explained. You can spend years finding information, piecing together your experiences ...
Read more
1 2 3 … 690

2 comments on “Critical Evaluation”

  1. As children we don't stop to question it; we all trust our parents advice and believe they are there for our best. Unfortunately for many, this is not the case.

    I have been told that an idyllic childhood doesn't prepare us for the challenges of adulthood and the relationships we go on to form. Perhaps that is why our childhood's are rarely great.

    As you say we have to learn to trust our own judgement. I did that from an early age, as I had no parental guidance, good or bad, but I wouldn't advocate that either.

    1. There is so much stress and strife in our lives, I'm not sure we ever get that idyllic childhood. Something always gets in the way.

      My experiences and my blogs continue to show that. I only know of one person who said she had an idyllic childhood and you're right, she wasn't prepared for certain aspects of her life, once she became an adult.

      Regardless of whether we have a good childhood or not, I still believe we have to form our own judgements, but we also have to have the ability to listen to our parent's advice; when it's given.

      I appreciate you didn't get that but there's always two sides to any story. I know in my own case, although I wasn't to blame initially for my issues based on my physical and emotional disabilities, I know I wasn't coping, neither did my parents. They gave up too easily; either through embarrassment, guilt or just not knowing how to help me.

      But if we dig deep, we usually find and know the answer. Our parents' decisions not to parent isn't a conscious decision. It comes about through an unconscious predisposition of circumstances and experiences that they fail to get a grip on and that's where we are partly responsible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to receive regular updates

Enter your details below to be the first to receive updates on new articles on my blog.