Nature shapes us through the genetic traits we inherit – everything from our physical features to aspects of our personality. Nurture, on the other hand, influences us through life experiences, the way we are raised, our relationships, and the environment we grow up in. While nature provides the blueprint, nurture plays a significant role in shaping how we develop and respond to the world around us.

Philosophers Plato and John Locke

Some philosophers including Plato, suggest that certain things are natural, or they occur naturally, regardless of environmental influences. Other well-known philosophers such as John Locke, suggest the mind begins as a blank page – everything that we are, and all of our knowledge is determined by our experiences and early conditioning.

Behaviours and Conditioning

Empiricists argue that most of our behaviours and traits come from learning and experience rather than genetics. They believe that conditioning shapes our actions and that, given the right environment, people can be trained to become anything, regardless of their genetic makeup.

This raises important questions. When someone excels academically, is it because they are naturally gifted, or has their environment nurtured their abilities? If a person has a violent temper, is it an inherited trait, or is it a learned response from observing those around them? Nature and nurture are deeply connected, influencing who we become in ways we may not always realise, think about, or understand.

Environmental Influences

Some characteristics are tied to environmental influences. How a person behaves can be linked to influences such as parenting styles and learned experiences. For example, a child might learn through observation and reinforcement to say 'please' and 'thank you.' Another child might learn to behave aggressively by observing their parents' behaviour.

Even today, research in psychology often tends to emphasise one influence over the other. What researchers do know is that it is the interaction between heredity and environment which is the most important factor of all. Throughout the history of psychology, this debate has continued to stir up controversy, although today, the majority of experts believe both nature and nurture influence behaviour and development.

Genetic Factors

More people are beginning to understand that asking whether heredity or environment has a greater influence on a trait is not the right question. The truth is, these influences are deeply intertwined and cannot be separated so easily. Genetics interact with one another, just as environmental factors – such as social experiences and cultural surroundings shape who we are. More importantly, heredity and environment do not work in isolation; they influence and shape each other in ways we can't full separate.

Conclusion

Although genetics and environment play their part, we can still learn things like empathy, compassion, tolerance and patience. There is room for change if we want to change. We should think about what we want to do with our lives and consider who we want to keep in our lives. When we ignore both our unconscious and conscious thinking, we will change nothing.

It is important not to rely on your parentage, instead we should nurture ourselves, once we're old enough to make our own decisions. (Source: verywellmind.com)

Ilana Estelle is a mental health and wellbeing advocate who combines educational insight with her personal experience of living with physical, mental, and emotional disabilities. She holds diplomas in Counselling, Diet and Nutrition, Nutritional Therapy, Psychotherapy and Counselling, and Stress Management. Through her writing, Ilana supports others in navigating their emotional, mental, and physical health challenges. In addition to writing for The CP Diary, her work has appeared in healthy lifestyle magazines. Ilana is also the author of three books: Cerebral Palsy: A Story – Finding the Calm After the Storm, Spirituality, Healing and Me, and Survival: The Covid Years – Time for Change.

Most people who read this blog

went on to read these blogs next
Date 20 July 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

The Power to Choose

Breaking free from expectations and embracing a life shaped by your own values Empowerment starts when we try something new. It's about taking action and believing that our choices can shape our lives. Many of ...
Read more
Date 16 July 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

Britain's Next Prime Minister

As Keir Starmer leaves office, attention turns to the challenges awaiting his successor Keir Starmer leaves office having described it as a privilege to serve as Prime Minister. Those words are worth reflecting on. Politics was once ...
Read more
Date 14 July 2026
Author Ilana Estelle

The Soul's Continuing Journey

How our choices, relationships, and experiences become part of the soul's continuing journey. My understanding of death is this: the greatest misunderstanding is believing that life ends. The physical body reaches its ...
Read more
1 2 3 521

4 comments on “Nature vs Nurture”

  1. I believe both Plato and John Locke are correct in their comparisons. Something significant happens in heredity factors as well as environmental factors, identity comes from both.

    But I'm inclined to believe that our past lives influence who we are, possibly to a large extent.

    1. Thanks Tim. Yes, I believe them also. I also agree with you, through my spiritual beliefs I believe our past lives also influence who we are to a large extent.

      Environmental and heredity factors are also a key factor with our parents conditioning us, but that said and as I have proved, we are all capable of change.

      The key lies in us not relying on our unconscious thinking, but consciously thinking about how we want our lives to go. We must also look at and deal with any past issues. Our past issues are what hold us back.

      There was so much from my own childhood that I know I needed to change. I remember having an internal conversation with myself about the things I needed to change.

      We can work to change most things, as long as we're not relying on our unconscious. It's our unconscious that ties us into our behaviour traits and patterns, without giving those our attention.

  2. I have always believed nurture played a greater role than nature but Tim raises an interesting point I hadn't considered before, and that makes sense too.

    Our past life experiences must contribute to an equal amount.

    1. Thanks. Yes, before we live a physical life we've already had spiritual lives before this and they do very much play their part in our lives.

      Of course being conditioned from a very early age doesn't help. It also doesn't help that parents parent as they have been parented.

      That's fine as long as the experience is positive, but I still believe we get to call the shots on some of our experiences and can change certain elements of ourselves.

      I don't think we try hard enough. There's never anything wrong with us, it's always someone else's fault.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to receive regular updates

Enter your details below to be the first to receive updates on new articles on my blog.